1. Non-Discrimination
2. Pro-Democracy
3. Egalitarianism

The Northern Territory Safe Measures Bill 2023 should be supported because it aims to provide vulnerable communities, particularly Aboriginal communities, with enhanced safety and reduced alcohol-related harm. The Bill aligns with the principles of non-discrimination by preserving the operation of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 and supports the democratic principle of community-led initiatives through Alcohol Management Plans [Judgment]. It also promotes egalitarianism by addressing disparities in health and safety outcomes caused by alcohol abuse.

The Bill's framework for community-driven Alcohol Management Plans empowers communities to take charge of their safety and well-being, fostering a sense of ownership and responsibility. The Commonwealth oversight ensures that these plans are consistent with human rights and effectively address the community's needs.

1. Value-Neutral / Epistemic Objection

While the Northern Territory Safe Measures Bill 2023 seeks to address serious issues, it can be argued that the reinstatement of measures from the Stronger Futures in the Northern Territory Act 2012 may not adequately consider the lessons learned from its past implementation failures. Critics may argue that the Bill could perpetuate paternalistic controls that do not sufficiently empower communities in the long term. The reliance on Commonwealth oversight may also be seen as undermining the autonomy of local governance structures and could lead to a one-size-fits-all approach that may not be effective in all communities [Judgment].

Additionally, there is a concern that the Bill's provisions could lead to stigmatization of Aboriginal communities, further entrenching social divisions rather than promoting inclusive solutions.