Electric Vehicles Accountability Bill 2021

High-Level Summary
The Electric Vehicles Accountability Bill 2021 aims to ensure that the Australian Government provides a clear national strategy for electric vehicles. It mandates annual statements regarding the strategy and international comparisons to be tabled in Parliament.

Summary
The Electric Vehicles Accountability Bill 2021 affects the legislative responsibilities of the Energy and Emissions Reduction Minister and the Productivity Minister. According to the bill, the Energy and Emissions Reduction Minister is required to table a comprehensive statement outlining Australia's electric vehicle strategy by August 1 each year. Additionally, Clause 4 of the bill mandates the Productivity Minister to direct the Productivity Commission to prepare an annual report that compares Australia's approach to electric vehicles with international practices. This report will focus on aspects such as support for the manufacture, purchase, and usage of electric vehicles. From the explanatory memo:
The purpose of this Bill is to ensure that the Australian Government provides a clear statement to the Australian Parliament of its approach to electric vehicles, including whether or not it has a national strategy.

Argument For
Normative Bases
  1. Environmentalism
  2. Pro-Democracy

The bill should be supported because it promotes transparency and accountability in Australia's approach to electric vehicles, encouraging the government to establish a coherent strategy. This will likely lead to more sustainable transportation options, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and benefiting the environment [Judgment]. Furthermore, by mandating international comparisons, the bill fosters informed decision-making and democratic engagement, ensuring that Australia remains competitive and aligned with global best practices.


Argument Against
Normative Bases
  1. Value-Neutral / Epistemic Objection

While the intention of the bill is commendable, it could be argued that the requirements it imposes may lead to bureaucratic inefficiencies and unnecessary administrative burdens. The annual reporting and comparison mandates might redirect resources that could be better used in direct support of electric vehicle adoption, such as incentives or infrastructure development [Judgment]. Additionally, the bill does not directly address the economic or logistical challenges of transitioning to electric vehicles, potentially limiting its effectiveness in promoting substantial change.


Date:

2021-06-16

Status:

Before Senate

Sponsor:

RICE, Sen Janet

Portfolio:

Unspecified

Categories:

Climate Change / Environment, Energy Policy, Democratic Institutions

Timeline:
16/06/2021
27/07/2022

Comments (0)