The Bill sets out new reporting requirements designed to equalise standards with those of public schools and increase transparency around financial practices that have come under scrutiny in the non-government sector.This alignment is intended to fill "inequitable transparency gaps" between the public and private sectors [Explanatory Memo page 2].
The primary justification for this Bill is the principle that public funding must be accompanied by public accountability. Currently, a significant "transparency gap" exists between public and private schools, despite both receiving substantial taxpayer support. By mandating that non-government schools disclose executive salaries, cash reserves, and student welfare statistics, the Bill ensures that the public can see exactly how their money is being spent and whether it is serving the educational interests of students [Judgment].
Furthermore, the strengthening of the "fit and proper person" test is a necessary step to protect the educational environment. The current system has been criticized for failing to hold authorities accountable for unethical behavior that does not meet a high criminal threshold. Expanding this test to include negligence and incompetence ensures that those entrusted with the care and education of children are held to a high professional standard. A public register of investigations also provides a vital check against "quiet" non-compliance, ensuring that parents and the community are informed of systemic issues within an institution.
While transparency is a laudable goal, this Bill represents a significant overreach into the autonomy of private institutions. Non-government schools are, by definition, independent entities that often serve specific religious or philosophical communities. Forcing these institutions to adopt the same reporting frameworks as public schools ignores their unique operational structures and may impose an undue administrative burden that diverts resources away from the classroom [Judgment].
The expansion of the "fit and proper person" test to include subjective criteria like "negligence" and "incompetence" is particularly concerning. These terms are broad and ill-defined, potentially giving the Minister excessive power to interfere in the governance of private schools based on political or ideological disagreements rather than objective misconduct. Additionally, the publication of a register of investigations before a final determination of non-compliance is reached could cause irreparable reputational damage to schools and individuals, violating the principle of procedural fairness. There is also a risk that disclosing detailed financial data, such as cash reserves and related-party transfers, could compromise the commercial privacy and financial stability of independent schools without providing a commensurate benefit to the public.
2026-11-18
Senate
Before Senate
ALLMAN-PAYNE, Sen Penny
Unspecified
Education, Democratic Institutions, Discrimination / Human Rights